Posted: Fri Nov 15, 2013 1:38 pm
That is just for today Al, the 10-day chart has 6 open, all the way to 174.87$Al_Dente wrote:""only one left open"""
THANK YOU boss
The Intraday US Stock Market Discussion Board
https://bbs.cobrasmarketview.com/
That is just for today Al, the 10-day chart has 6 open, all the way to 174.87$Al_Dente wrote:""only one left open"""
THANK YOU boss
joegamma wrote:Royal Flush wrote:joegamma wrote:TRIN MIGHT GIVE A SELL SIGNAL NEXT DAY OR SO, bretz rule needs 5 day avg below 4.0Hi joegamma, please explain "TRIN MIGHT GIVE A SELL SIGNAL NEXT DAY OR SO, bretz rule needs 5 day avg below 4.0" the 5 day avg would always be below 4.0 as TRIN is seldom above 4.0
5 days with trin at 0.80 is summed to 4.0, (ie .80 * 5) just the method that Bretz proposed (from Market Breadth Indicators book)...stockcharts cannot sum, so I used 6day ATR as a so-so visual proxy, you can add 'em by hand too
and also look here ... http://thebuttonwoodtree.wordpress.com/ ... he-market/fehro wrote:bored?... check out some interesting charts... http://www.bespokeinvest.com/
How very honorable of our Music Fan to share some evidence of scar tissue! thats what makes the KingSnake's board the best!! thanks for the clarificationMr. BachNut wrote:I think it is a 5 day total not average. You would use an average of 0.8 as a threshold.Royal Flush wrote:Hi joegamma, please explain "TRIN MIGHT GIVE A SELL SIGNAL NEXT DAY OR SO, bretz rule needs 5 day avg below 4.0" the 5 day avg would always be below 4.0 as TRIN is seldom above 4.0joegamma wrote:TRIN MIGHT GIVE A SELL SIGNAL NEXT DAY OR SO, bretz rule needs 5 day avg below 4.0For a strong rally, we need a surge in NYADV, or a drop in nyhgh from these levels, normally ratio needs lower still looking at these and wondering if we are in a new leg up or not and, RARE to see the amex highs have negative slope, not sure what it implies
I have some experience (read scar tissue) on this.
I have found that win rates on this are dramatically different depending on whether you are in a bull trend or bear trend.
The signal has good tradeable odds in a bear trend, but it is a coin flip in a bull trend IMO.
That said, it is worth keeping an eye on in a bull trend because the times it does work (52%) are often at highs/tops.
Thanks joegamma, the only book I am aware of on the subject is:"The Complete Guide To Market Breadth Indicators" by Gregory Morris, is this the one you are referring to?joegamma wrote:Royal Flush wrote:Hi joegamma, please explain "TRIN MIGHT GIVE A SELL SIGNAL NEXT DAY OR SO, bretz rule needs 5 day avg below 4.0" the 5 day avg would always be below 4.0 as TRIN is seldom above 4.0joegamma wrote:TRIN MIGHT GIVE A SELL SIGNAL NEXT DAY OR SO, bretz rule needs 5 day avg below 4.0For a strong rally, we need a surge in NYADV, or a drop in nyhgh from these levels, normally ratio needs lower still looking at these and wondering if we are in a new leg up or not and, RARE to see the amex highs have negative slope, not sure what it implies
5 days with trin at 0.80 is summed to 4.0, (ie .80 * 5) just the method that Bretz proposed (from Market Breadth Indicators book)...stockcharts cannot sum, so I used 6day ATR as a so-so visual proxy, you can add 'em by hand too
Outstanding!!Al_Dente wrote:hard to see a "win win" here