The earthquake in the bond market continues, but it doesn’t look as violent on the weeklies.
Here are two “Risk to Safety Ratios,” or the ratios of corporate and junk bonds (risk) compared to government bonds (safety) over the longer term.
A few things jump out:
1) The ratios have predictive power, especially evidenced by the fact that both bottomed a full 4-5 months before the SPX March 2009 bottom
(meaning that investors started buying risk bonds 4-5 months before they bought back into stocks).
2) Risk is still on. Today, investors still prefer risk bonds over safe gov bonds, as they have since late 2008.
3) Corporates to Governments Ratio (top panel) is starting to look like a wedge pattern.
4) Folks are backing off from Junk bonds (considered the riskiest; middle panel) in favor of corporates (“less” risk; top panel). Typically folks dump their riskier bonds first, when they start getting nervous; note the selloff last year in junk was deeper than the selloff in corporates.
So, you could say that the Junk to Gov Ratio (middle panel) is calling for a SPX top because of its non-confirmation of highs,
and we can add that to our long list of bear SPX indicators.
4) Note in the bottom panel: IF (
and that is a big important IF) investors continue selling off their government bonds,
that should be bullish for stocks (and also bullish for risk bonds).
[Caveat: These are Al Dente kool-aid charts that I just made up, so any opposing/correcting views are appreciated.
I still favor my “industry standard” Stock to Bond Ratio (it’s still risk-on) but I just wanted a pure bond market view of things.
Also, the moves in the bond market often give us “leading” signals, but as you can see, the MA moving average crossover is a lagging signal, not leading.]